Tuesday, May 06, 2008

Shields Shall be Splintered!

I'm working on giving the shield a bit more love in my Moldvay/Cook/LL hack. The shield really doesn't get the prestige it deserves. There's a reason it was a staple of the infantryman's gear from the dawn of history all the way into the 17th century. Shields work. They stop blows, they can be moved to intercept attacks coming from almost any direction, and they can be used to attack your foes. Simply lowering your AC by a mere point is hardly representative of the value of a good shield.

However, things are complicated by my adoption of some popular houserules for weapon damage. To whit, I'm considering tossing the plethora of different dice types for weapons and just adopting 1d6 for single-handed weapons and 2d4 for two-handed weapons. This is a variation on schemes I've seen elsewhere. Fighting with two weapons allows you to roll 2d6, and you take the better roll.

So you can see that there's a lot of value to fighting without a shield in improving the damage your character dishes out, making the shield an even less likely choice. What can be done to rehabilitate the shield and make it a worthwhile choice mechanically?

I'm considering allowing the shield to act as ablative armour. One thing historical shields frequently did was shatter. A strong blow with an axe or a sword could cleave a shield, splintering the boards. Viking duels often had a three-shield rule, allowing each combatant to enter the contest with a shield on his arm and two spares in reserve. (I believe this was seen in "The 13th Warrior", but it's been a while since I've watched it, so my memory could be faulty.)

With my houserule, you get the usual -1 to your AC with a shield. However, any time you take damage, you can opt instead to say your shield absorbed the force of the blow. The shield is shattered and must be discarded, but you don't take any damage from that hit. It's quick, it's easy, and it's valuable.

What about magic? Should a shield ward you against the ferocity of a fireball or a lightning bolt? My instinct is to say yes, but that makes a shield incredibly valuable, and takes a lot of the sting out of those spells. Maybe you can sacrifice the shield in exchange for an automatic save and half damage? Do you get to decide after you've rolled the save, or do you have to choose before you roll? We can go crazy with this and say that shields crafted from the wood of the rowan tree can be sacrificed for a successful save versus any spell, even those that don't deal damage directly.

What about magical shields? I'm kinda meh about the idea of mundane swords being able to shatter magical shields. On the other hand, I certainly don't want a warrior being able to just ignore hits every round because his shield won't break. Maybe each +1 gives the shield a 10% chance to survive the blow? Maybe I just won't have magical shields in my campaign? Seriously, in the quarter-century-plus I've been playing D&D, I think I can count the number of magical shields in my games on one hand.

(I also considered allowing the shield to give its bearer an AC of 3 versus a single opponent, but then you have to keep track of who it's been used against, and the character's AC jumps around between 3 and whatever their armour grants. It's a lot more hassle in the thick of dice-rolling. And I just love the visceral feel of shields being cloven in twain under the blows of a dangerous foe.)

226 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 226 of 226
aliza said...

Silver Limousines around the Silver Seacoast is an inexpensive Limousine Assistance along with grow and car limousines running around the Silver Seacoast, Gold Coast Limo X

Sela Pervaz said...

Silver Limousines around the Silver Seacoast is an inexpensive Limousine Assistance along with grow and car limousines running around the Silver Seacoast, Gold Coast Limo X.

schedim said...

Really good ideas in here, shields has buggered me a lot for ages, and some of the ideas presented in here solves most of the problems i had!

Now I have to go through the whole blog for more nuggets!

This website said...

Nice website this is! I just visited aanrechtblad-kopen.nl. It looks like they have almost a fashion website with how the stones are presented.

pharmaceutical drop shipping said...

I am thoroughly convinced in this said post. I am currently searching for ways in which I could enhance my knowledge in this said topic you have posted here. It does help me a lot knowing that you have shared this information here freely

Allain said...

Not sure if this comment is related.. but it is still a comment. As I have seen such unrelated comments.. you might want to check this out for "repairs"

http://24hourlocksmith.com.au/electronic-security-vulnerabilities/

pembesar penis said...

nice is the article thanks
obat pembesar penis

Allain said...

Sharing something on the site

http://24hourlocksmith.com.au/

semarangshop.com said...

Ba mhaith liom buíochas a fheiceáil na poist níos mó cosúil le seo!
pembesar penis

Sania Zahra said...

Nice blog! The content is impress me. Thanks for sharing.
verhuisbedrijf hilversum

Earn Online High School Diploma said...

Extraordinary post! Also mind boggling website! Extremely accommodating post! I must say. Basic & intriguing Wonderful work!

Visit: Earn Online High School Diploma

mainan edukatif said...

I think this is one of the most important information for me. And i am glad reading your article cuy

Online Poker said...

Wow! This is a nice post shared here. Great article and thanks for sharing.

Chang bui thi said...

Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.
juegosjuegos | juegos de matar | jogos do friv

High School Diploma Program said...

Great sharing you have done here continue great sharing.

Online Rummy said...

Your post is very informative.This is obviously one great post. I keep on reading articles from here.thanks for sharing..

iniciar sesion facebook entrar said...

I am happy to find this post very useful for me
Signature:
facebook entrar iniciar sesion gratis - Sitio Oficial iniciado sesión en Facebook lengua española. facebook entrar rápido, facebook iniciar sesion en tu cuenta de entrar facebook

Custom Logo Design Company said...

I will try my best to do like that. That's a called a creative thinking. Nice post dude. Share some more like that.

Medical and Health Care Logos | Corporate Logo Design

Rummy Rules said...

Great post,I look forward to more posts.

Online Poker said...

Thanks for taking time to share your great thoughts and ideas about the subject.

Anonymous said...

Look, I get the "visceral feel" sentiment you're trying to capture, I really do, but...
I don't know if this has been addressed above (I don't have time to comb through 200 posts - and if it has, then it needs to be updated in the main post), as I read this rule, it looked "instantly abusable" to a hilarious degree. I don't know what the availability of shields are in your game, but looking at the SRD, bucklers are 5 gp and weigh only 5 lb.

So of *course* everybody's gonna load up on those, and even more so after they get bags of holding. Heck, I'd carry one around in real life (that's what, $100 w/ the typical 1 gp = $20 conversion rate) if it meant I could get hit by a truck and walk away unscathed.

And when that shatters, I simply reach into my bag or bandoleer and pull out another one. And thus I have a "Get out of damage for 5 gp card".

Ancient Red Dragon bites at me for 35 damage? Tell it to my replaceable buckler.

No one could survive falling off the Cliffs of Insanity? Not if I jump buckler first!

Ground Zero of a nuclear detonation? Buckler, faithful ol' chap, he took one for the team...





trollsmyth said...

Anonymous: At first, your question confused me, but then I noticed you referencing the SRD and then your comments made a lot more sense.

In most versions of D&D, readying a shield requires time. In 3.x D&D, anyone with any attack bonus gets to do it as a free action. In addition, in most versions of D&D, treasure is part of your encumbrance; if you wanted to carry dozens of shields, that would mean leaving behind treasure and therefore earning little to no EXP. Again, that's not the case in 3.x D&D.

All that said, I do believe you need both hands free to cast spells in 3.x D&D and shield-toting types tend to get left in the dust by the spell-slingers. I could be wrong about that, as I can't find anything to that effect in the SRD at a cursory glance. But if you can't carry a shield and cast spells, then I'd see this as a good way to level the playing field between wizards and fighters.

On the other hand, if that's not the case, and most especially if you're the sort of DM who would allow a shield to protect against falling damage or nuclear strike, then you probably shouldn't use this rule.

games unblocked said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Nicky Paul said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Rahul saini said...

That's great news!Your article is written in a manner way, i really enjoyed this.

Alamin Miah said...

I absolutely love your blog and find almost all of your post’s to be just what I’m looking for. can you offer guest writers to write content to suit your needs? I wouldn’t mind publishing a post or elaborating on a lot of the subjects you write with regards to here. Again, awesome website! globalexa.snack.ws

almostakbl company said...

تنظيف مكيفات بالرياض

ظلت دائما اجهزه تكييف الهواء هي من اهم العوامل التي تقدم المساعده والعون االي الانسان حيث انها تدعمه علي تحمل تقلبات الجو سواء الحراره العاليه او الحراره المنخفضة ، وان رفاهيه الانسان تعتمد بشكل كبير علي مكيفات الهواء وكل ذلك يعتمد علي حالة مكيف الهواء لديكم حيث انه من الواجب دائما عمل صيانة وتنظيف بشكل مستمر لمكيفات الهوات الهواء فان ادائها يعتمد بشكل كبير علي ذلك حيث انها من الممكن مع عدم صيانتها وتنظيفها بشكل منتظم ان تؤدي الي عطلها ان وانهياراها تماما ، فيما يلي بعض النصائح الهامة حول كيفية الرعاية بمكيف الهواء الخاص بك …
تنظيف مكيفات
- اذا كنت تعيش بمنطقة قريبة بشكل كبير من المناطق الصناعية ، فيجب عليك الاهتمام بشكل كبير بتنظيف المكيفات بشكل مستمر وعلي فترات متقاربة اكثر من اي منطقة سكنيه اخري فيجب عليك دائما الاستعانة بـ تنظيف مكيفات بالرياض
للقيام عملية الصيانة والتنظيف الدورية بالنيابة عنك ، او اذا كانت لديك الخبره الكافية بذلك فمن الممكن عمل الصيانة بنفسك غير ذلك قد تكون حالة المكيف لديك علي المحك لذلم فانت دائما تحتاج الي تنظيف المكيفات بالرياض .
شركة تنظيف مكيفات
- اذا كنت من هواه مقتني الحيوانات الاليفة مثل القطط او الكلاب او غيرها من الحيوانات الاليفة فذلك من اهم الاسباب التي تحتم عليك العناية جيدا بنظافة المكيفات بالرياض بشكل دائم ومستمر فان الفراء الناتج من هذه الحيوانات دائما ما يتحد مع ذرات الغبار والتي تعمل علي انسداد وتضييق فتحات الفلاتر والغاز الخاص بالفريون داخل المكيف مما قد يؤدي مع الوقت الي تلف المكيف فلذلك فان شركة تنظيف المكيفات بالرياض هوا من اهم العوامل الاساسية التي تحافظ دائما علي عمر مكيف الهواء لديكم .

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 226 of 226   Newer› Newest»