tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-28751902.post4407222554039628354..comments2024-03-26T02:31:48.024-05:00Comments on Trollsmyth: Monster Manual Cage Fight!trollsmythhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/01895349218958093151noreply@blogger.comBlogger5125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-28751902.post-5542019332397716912016-10-25T04:02:14.002-05:002016-10-25T04:02:14.002-05:00@trollsmyth looking at the screenshot, the first t...@trollsmyth looking at the screenshot, the first thing that hits me is "block of text" the second is "I can't use this." At the table I absolutely won't have time for this and in my free time ... I'll do other things, like work, read novels, go for walks.<br /><br />I'm with you on the analysis. This is trying to be a novel, not a game tool.Lukahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/18210941654513813581noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-28751902.post-26262598328916048732016-10-24T10:06:31.757-05:002016-10-24T10:06:31.757-05:00Yora: Thanks! If you do something cool with that ...<b>Yora:</b> Thanks! If you do something cool with that idea, please let us know.trollsmythhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/01895349218958093151noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-28751902.post-6107308889103552222016-10-24T10:05:53.869-05:002016-10-24T10:05:53.869-05:00Ed Ortiz: eh, maybe.
On the one hand, sure, offer...<b>Ed Ortiz:</b> eh, maybe.<br /><br />On the one hand, sure, offering guidance for new DMs is a good thing, but you can also overwhelm. You already can't run nearly all the monsters in D&D without looking at the stat block (which almost always means flipping through the MM). Is the DM now going to have to flip through Volo's as well? How many books are you expecting the DM to juggle at a time? I already avoid opening the DMG at the table because I've got to keep flipping through the PHB and the MM when running encounters, and most of my pre-game prep involves filling both books with sticky-notes. If I'm just using the new monsters in Volo's, that's fine; I can close the MM and set it aside. But if you're expecting me to have all three books open at the table at once? That's a bit more juggling than I, an experienced DM, really want to bother with. <br /><br />If WotC did this right, that means that most of the background will be used in adventure prep and not need referencing at the table. What I hope we'll get are random tables to help DMs construct orc tribes, maps of illithid hives, and just solid advice explaining how to make the most of using each monster in an adventure. What I suspect we'll get is a lot of flowery writing containing some well-worn lore that's already widely know. (Take this page for instance: https://cdn2.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/7301811/Screenshot%202016-10-18%2015.19.20.png. The tadpoles are new to 5e, but the elder brains, the hive-mind colonies, and the rogues are all things mentioned in the MM. What does Volo's add about the elder brain and the colony that didn't already exist in MM? Not much, and they took most of a page to say it.) What I fear we'll get is long, dry, boring chapters that ramble on without really giving anything to DMs willing to put in the effort to read it. <br /><br />I applaud WotC for trying something new, but I doubt they've gone far enough. They're still in "selling books" mode and not in "how is this going to be used at the table" mode. Volo and Elminster sparring might make for an entertaining read, but what does it give us that we can use at the table? What examples and guidance are new DMs being given? Or are they being saddled with details only useful to pedants? trollsmythhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/01895349218958093151noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-28751902.post-55272828572805098822016-10-24T03:07:55.373-05:002016-10-24T03:07:55.373-05:00I really like the idea of using monsters to use as...I really like the idea of using monsters to use as clues for what's going on in the adventure.<br /><br />Incidentially, the monster comes from Latin for "showing/indicating".Yorahttp://spriggans-den.comnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-28751902.post-39350422453847500462016-10-23T22:16:52.017-05:002016-10-23T22:16:52.017-05:00I found it interesting to see that Volo's MM h...I found it interesting to see that Volo's MM has caused a stir in the community. Recently, some of my Payday 2 crew have started DMing for the first time. Some have played RPGs before, but many are new. Their reaction to Volo has been one that is positive, especially for the background information and fluff that the book provides. My buddy, who is DMing his first game, doesn't quite feel completely confident in his abilities at world building. He is happy to read the fluff and use that, plus build off of it for his own game. Some of my other friends that are budding DMs feel the same way.<br /><br />And I think that's something to remember. These products are made with the new GM and busy GM in mind. While this fluff may be useless to those of us that have been doing this for years, for the newbie, it gives them some interesting background into how they would like to run a monster. What's even better is that many new GMs become empowered to create their own fluff for creatures, using this background information as a jumping point. Which is the opposite of what some people have complained about the MM. <br /><br />I think we need to remember that not everyone that are buying these books are experienced in GMing. And these books help to ease an otherwise unconfident GM into the reigns of running a campaign. I think that's a good value for the product.Opiyelhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02417788307268767696noreply@blogger.com